Judge Stops DAPA and New DACA

A federal judge in Texas temporarily stopped the expanded DACA and DAPA programs. Today, February 18, 2015, USCIS was supposed to begin accepting applications for expanded DACA (Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals). DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson issued a press release acknowledging the decision to shut down the two programs temporarily before they even began accepting applications.

The lawsuit involved 26 states that argued the Obama Administration had exercised substantive and legislative powers that only belong to the legislative branch. Executive actions pertaining to immigration have been issued by every president since Eisenhower. The government noted that deferral actions have been taken since the 1960s in their brief. The judge agreed with the 26 states, finding unconstitutionality in his order. DHS vows that it will appeal the decision. The Office of Legal Counsel, which serves an advisory role for the executive branch, issued an opinion on November 19, 2014 (the day before the executive actions were announced by President Obama). The opinion advised that DAPA and an expanded DACA program would be legal and within the constitutional powers of the president.

The older version of DACA remains in effect and the recipients of DACA are not affected by this decision.

That first version of DACA was not at issue in the lawsuit, though it was tangentially mentioned and criticized. Seeing as over half of the states participated in bringing this lawsuit and the Obama Administration and DHS are planning to appeal, more court battles are expected over the separation of powers, adherence to the Administrative Procedure Act, and DAPA and DACA. The president issued his series of executive orders in November 2014 as a result of congressional inability to pass comprehensive or incremental immigration reform that has been clamored for years. The Senate passed immigration reform in 2013, providing a pathway to citizenship, but that bill did not become law because the House voted against it.